This chair is very cute and works as advertised but is still not a good fit for my large 4-year old. The detachable potty shield won't fit between his legs at all. He fills up the seat and the edge of the potty bowl still leaves uncomfortable marks after he sits for a while. The magazine rack is a bit blocked by the arm rest. It does rock well but may need to be buttressed at the back. The lid works very well, is easy to take out, as is the potty bowl. One good thing about this chair for larger kids is that it sits up higher and doesn't require their legs to be scrunched up while they go.